← Main Menu  |  Book Contents  |  ← Chapter 4  |  Chapter 5  |  Chapter 6 →

The Rise and Fall Of The NEW Four Seasons 1966 to 1977

Chapter 5 - The Rise From The ‘Ashes’ Of Motown

By the fall of 1972, Bob Gaudio and Frankie Valli were still believing that the MoWest experiment was going to re-vitalise their careers and the Four Seasons list of hit records. This was despite no success from either the critically acclaimed but poor selling 'Chameleon' album or their efforts with the label's in-house LA based producers.

Whilst the belief was still there in the group themselves and core fans.....MoWest were starting to ‘unravel’ and in particular Berry Gordy who was distracted by his involvement emotionally and professionally, due to his affair with Diana Ross and her emerging film career. It is evident in his biography, ‘To Be Loved” as is the slow decline also of the ‘main brand’ of Motown during this period . What was going wrong now that Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons were back on the main label?

Dave Pell a former executive with MoWest had a view that spelled out a warning that eventually Bob Crewe, Bob Gaudio and Frankie Valli could not ignore. “Berry was chasing a dream. His very special gift for pop song writing was abandoned in an attempt to re-create the flavour of the jazz clubs he had haunted as a teen...... Meanwhile, the record division would battle an industry trend that had already changed the shape of black music...... Motown record division floundered......Part of the reason could be traced to the departure of Barney Ales. From the very beginning, Ales had been squeezing distributors for overdue dollars and pushing his salesmen: he was the business backbone of Motown....if Berry had provided Motown Records with inspiration, Barney’s ability to get money had been its guts. Without either of these men active in the company, Motown became just another record company.”

Chapter 5 illustration

And not a well run one!

1972 finished with more lost master recordings recorded by Frankie Valli, 'I Can't Get Away From You (But I Can't Get Over You)' was a song recorded and release on Motown's VIP label [25068F] by Tony and Carolyn in 1971. Another song written by Michael and Pam Sawyer, it has a Master Nr 61588 as recorded by Frankie Valli immediately following that of 'Minute By Minute....' so must reside on Tapes P2351/2 which paper records show cover these sessions with Michael Masser co-producing with Frankie Valli. This provides further evidence of yet another unreleased track that make us wonder about the productions...and the amazing ineptitude of Motown to not release such material at the time. Michael Masser would go on to be an award winning producer in the following decades with Diana Ross, George Benson and Whitney Houston.

Chapter 5 illustration

Then, Bob Crewe was finally back in the studio with Frankie Valli in November 1972 recording a song 'Be My Lover, Be My Friend' [Master Nr 61663 - Un-released], written by him and legendary 60s songwriter and friend Ellie Greenwich with former Four Evers member Steve Tudanger. Other songs from Bob Crewe sessions at the time remain unheard in 'Turn It All Around' [Master Nr 62131 – Unreleased] and 'Give Us This Day'[Master Nr 62132 - Unreleased]. The Master tapes still exist but they remain unreleased in 2026 …....53 years on!!!.

However other tracks from these sessions were strong and would cause Motown to review their potential. Sessions around this time also include the recording of 'Star' [Master Nr 61746] a Crewe -Gaudio penned song and production that featured the then Four Seasons [we believe] on backing vocals. This song heard for the first time on release in 2023 has proved to be totally original …..fast...then, slow and harmonic, in structure which today seems very ahead of its time. This is an example of an opportunity missed by Motown. Any artist would have been frustrated by such quality going to waste.

But for Frankie Valli this period in his career is part of a ‘Lesson In Survival’ as Rex Woodard recalled in his Billboard Article in 1981..... “Still, in 1973 the Four Seasons had gained their reputation on records and across the airwaves. The band’s older members, Valli, Long and Gaudio, felt increased pressure to turn the corner on this segment of their career. Could that corner be turned however? What other American group had stayed on top for so long? The Beach Boys were in a terrible mess at the time themselves. Maybe the effort was futile. To make matters worse, Valli was growing deaf. It took tremendous amplification for him to just hear himself sing. The frustration began peaking in early March 1973. During a Puerto Rican gig, drummer Wilson quit without notice. This infuriated Valli, who wanted to cancel the group’s remaining engagements. Ken Roberts, the group’s manager, ordered Valli to hire a replacement. If worse came to worse, and they couldn’t find one in time, their repertoire was not so difficult that a session man couldn’t have stood in for a short time.

The quartet continued to perform with a substitute drummer, but the group suffered from unresolved internal conflicts. Roberts had scheduled another English tour for April followed by a German television special and a May tour of South Africa. The crisis came to a head on 25 March 1973 during a concert at the Capitol Theatre in Passaic, New Jersey. The time came for Deloach to sing his solo selection. He refused saying his throat hurt. Valli, a 20 year veteran who had experienced hecklers, derelict drunks, gay bars and damp basement taverns, was dumbfounded at Deloach’s lackadaisical attitude towards his audience. The spectators never noticed this short scene, and the show was completed, but Valli exploded backstage. Valli angrily pro- claimed his retirement and his intention to disband the Four Seasons. With that, he departed for a lengthy “rest” to an unknown destination.

Clearly, Valli was near the point of a total breakdown. His stomach ulcers bothered him, he couldn’t hear a damn thing and he couldn’t adapt to performing without Gaudio’s presence. To add to his other problems his 13 year marriage had gone down the drain. Gaudio, Callas and Long conferred with manager, Roberts, in hopes of saving the overseas tour. Jordan and Ruzicka were possibly available to rejoin the group but for what purpose with no lead singer? To no one’s surprise, Valli’s “retirement” ended in a matter of a few weeks. Valli had overcome too many obstacles to chuck it all this quick.”. ...said Rex . [ed.Confusion remains re the exact details and memories from this traumatic period in the group’s tenure, but I have elected to stick with Rex’s version]

Years had passed with marriage break-ups for Gaudio and Valli and Crewe's breakdown and this time enabled them to re-build their personal lives which inevitably had impacted on their music. But the music is the music and the chance to earn good money again appeared in 1973. The future direction of the Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons was about to change.

The group as said in Chapter 4 were ‘gone’ as a live act for a period and as a result of this debacle they may not have been good enough to have contributed to assisting Valli in the studio during early 1973 as there was no settled group to fulfil the booked sessions, Joe Long highlighted there non appearance on the released ‘How Come’ Crewe and Gaudio enlisted session singers to complete the tracks and change the sound and style of Frankie Valli's recordings whilst preserving the ‘harmony’ sound of the backing vocals..

Chapter 5 illustration

Bob Crewe tapped into the stunning quality he had achieved with Bobby Darin in late 1972 and used Motown backing vocalists with the new songs written and produced by Crewe and Gaudio on the little known and under-appreciated 'With My Eyes Wide Open' and 'Listen To Yesterday'. These recordings on MasterTapes P2388 and 89 have mixing dates of February 1973. The BETTER original STEREO Mix of ‘With My Eyes Wide Open' surfaced in our 2020 research even though a ‘mix’ with heavy echo and overdub had appeared on the belated “Inside You’ album in 1975. This ‘Re-Master’ change by Russ Terrana infuriated Bob Gaudio at the time and set the tone of his wanting to leave all of the Motown period behind. He didn’t need it even if we did and still do. This nearly lost mix now appears on my You Tube page and can be heard via this link

Chapter 5 illustration

But again MoWest/Motown would stun Frankie and Bob. We know this from Rex from his Billboard article.....”This year the Philips litigation ended with the Four Seasons attaining the rights to all their recorded masters from 1962 through to 1970. This placed the fellows in an absolutely unique status, one not shared by the Beatles, Beach Boys, Elvis, Rolling Stones or any other major act. They offered to sell this valuable acquisition to Motown and were shocked when the company showed no interest. This turn of events later proved to be providential; today they periodically lease the catalogue to various labels, retaining ownership, artistic control and the resulting barrels of bucks. Longines Symphonette Society agreed to a lucrative lease agreement to issue a massive 60 song, four record set entitled “The Greatest Hits Of Frankie Valli And The Fabulous Four Seasons”. Incredibly 350,000 four record sets sold via television orders in the first five months. The tide was turning, the public was beginning to remember just how much it enjoyed the “sound” of the Four Seasons. “ Strangely there is no record of what Masters were used for this set and it remains today ‘unresearched’ in that respect as no digital transfer of these Masters has ever been done and no Master Safety Tapes found in the Partnership tape storage.

Rex picks up the story again…….“By April 1973 whilst not in the studio sessions, the Four Seasons were again doing engagements. With all the changes, few noticed the young drummer added to the back-up group: Gerald M Polci. Little was known about Polci at the time except for his close association with Joe Morello of the Dave Brubeck Quartet. When Jordan finally left for school, the absence of Jordan’s singing left a gap in the harmony. Drummer Polci volunteered to supplement the back-up vocals. What a pleasant surprise when they gave him a microphone! Polci possessed one of the best voices of anyone ever associated with the Four Seasons. Polci comfortably assumed permanent membership in the Four Seasons. Polci was 21 years old, born 9 June 1952 in Passaic, New Jersey. His first performance as a Season came in Chicago. “

[Gerry Polci had played with the Montclair State College Jazz Band whilst at Montclair State University, New Jersey, up to 1973, from where he joined the Four Seasons when invited by the group’s then saxophonist...ed]

Sessions in Spring 1973 only included Frankie Valli and Motown session singers for the backing on the harmonic . With the group membership so fluid Bob Crewe showed he could create the backing harmonies he and Bob Gaudio could design and he did on 'How Come' (Sherman – Sherman) a song from the 1973 musical United Artists film Tom Sawyer, starring Jodie Foster. Gaudio did the vocal arrangements with Crewe producing. Motown promoted the disc using a 1971 group photograph. The George Clinton composition ’Life and Breath’ was on the ‘B’ side from a year earlier session with Hal Davis producing. The single version has a spoken intro by the Four Seasons whereas the later ‘Inside You’ album version does not. Just another example of the many alternate mixes they did in sessions.The US Motown’s operational formula required a charting lead single to build market momentum before pressing and distributing a full-length LP. In early 1973, Motown released the single "How Come" / "Life and Breath"(Motown 1255) to test the waters.  The single was poorly promoted and flopped commercially. Because the single failed to gain traction, Motown executives lost confidence that the band could succeed in the current market, refusing to invest further capital into pressing their second album without proof of commercial viability. Motown cancelled the 1973 album ‘Inside Out ‘(assigned catalog number Motown 788) just weeks before its slated August release primarily because Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons “failed to deliver a hit single to justify the album’s release,” combined with deep internal corporate chaos at the label

Motown also tried with a Valli solo 45 with the re-worked ‘You’ve Got Your Troubles’ (yet again)[of 'Fortunes' fame] in a morose ballad style arrangement as had been done at Philips in 1970 [but as a new extended Master,] coupled with a newly recorded ‘Listen To Yesterday’, a classic Crewe—Gaudio composition on Motown 1251F. It might have had success if the A/B sides had been reversed. The original B side of the 45 features superb female backing vocals by Motown session singers whilst the 'alternative' version features 'surf sounds' on the intro and a Beach Boys type harmony backing with equally superb male Motown backing singers. Perhaps an idea to appeal to a West Coast image? This 'previously unreleased' version which first appeared in the 2008 The Motown Anthology 2 CD set demonstrated why the research of many unreleased or alternate 'takes' still in the vaults is justified. It inspired our research throughout the 2010s. Both are 'essential' Collector's Items'. Unreleased tracks from the ‘How Come’ session tapes (16 track Tapes 2511 and 24 track Tape 2656) at this time reveal songs, 'Sitting On The Edge Of My Mind', 'When I Come Of Age' and 'Coming Home'. All 3 remain ‘unreleased’

The transitions at Motown and within the group caused immense internal confusion, management turnover, and a lack of clear artistic direction. Lost in the corporate shuffle, Frankie Valli's project lacked an internal executive champion to push it past the finish line given that producer Bob Crewe had successfully discovered a sweeping, romantic ballad sound for Frankie Valli during these early 1973 sessions, yielding tracks like "Inside You".and 'Listen To Yesterday'. These recordings on Tapes 2388 and 89 have mixing dates of February 1973. While Crewe and Bob Gaudio believed this was the ideal artistic direction, Motown management—including Suzanne de Passe—did not see how to market a traditional pop-ballad act. The label prioritised its homegrown progressive R&B and urban pop acts (like the Commodores and the Jackson 5),. Bob Gaudio as well as Bob Crewe had separately completed sessions and tried to find a song to bring solo success with Frankie Valli . The 1973–1974 sessions produced by Bob Crewe for the Four Seasons’ planned second Motown album resulted in what we fans regard as a legendary "lost album".  Motown had pulled the plug on ‘Inside Out ‘Someday maybe someone will re-construct it

Following the late 1972 release in the UK, ‘The Night’ was getting significant play at Wigan Casino and other clubs on the Northern Soul scene in the UK by mid 1973........this cult track had found a home....…the UK was making a ‘noise’ !

The frustrations of the previous four years continued unabated in summer 1973 . Rex Woodard again provides background to Frankie Valli’s career......”On 13 July convicted felon and “stoolie” Gerald Zeimanowitz testified before a US Senate Sub Committee that the Four Seasons were connected with the Mafia. Allegedly, according to Zeimanowitz, mobster Angelo “Gyp” DeCarlo of New Jersey owned a “piece” of the band. DeCarlo had been imprisoned in 1970 but pardoned by President Nixon in 1972. Zeimanowitz, however, really had his facts mixed up judging from his testimony, and probably confused the Four Seasons with another act (Valli, when asked about the charge kept his humour: He just wanted to know why his career was going so lousy despite these so-called friends in influential positions!).” Valli at the time was very sensitive to this news and was concerned it would alienate his fans if found to be true. Now he admits this involvement in the ‘Jersey Boys’ show and book and the association seems of little harm although it may be ‘fictionalised’ in the stage show. His associations/re-unions with his New Jersey 'friends' was well known at 'residencies' at Bachelors III in Fort Lauderdale for summer weeks in 1973 and 74 which we have captured in good quality LIVE recordings in the Snapper Music Box Set.

In mid-1973, Suzanne de Passe served as the vice president of creative operations (and previously director of the West Coast creative division) for Motown Records. She shaped the artistic vision, style, and stage presentation for top company acts including The Commodores featuring Lionel Richie. She remained in her Executive role, and is an icon of Motown today as a veteran of over three decades in Hollywood. But in 1973 at Motown she very specifically failed to promote Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons and missed a great opportunity to create a hit for them and that was part of the reasons that would eventually lead them away to better things. It was a ‘spontaneous’ attempt by the group to prove their talent which would become the ‘touchstone’ for the name ‘THE FOUR SEASONS’ to become the biggest group they had ever been. As Valli recruited new members Gerry Polci, and Lee Shapiro to join Joe Long and Demetri Callas after the departure of Bill Deloach, the vocal and instrumental capability was significantly enhanced by mid 1973 and as the group personally presented to Suzzane De Passe a master recording they had composed and recorded themselves on the road hoping for a single release in the summer Demetri Callas picks up the story of a song that barely survived yet is so well loved by Four Seasons fans that it gained its first commercial release in 2023:-

“The group was playing in Southern Maryland , a 10 day or 12 day engagement and we were staying in the town. We had too much time on our hands, the show was in the evening, we were playing two performances in the evening, finished by midnight”.

“Myself, Joe, Gerry Polci, who was the drummer at the time, Lee Shapiro – Lee and Gerry were new to the act - composed a song with The 4 Seasons in mind called “I Wonder Why” and all of us musicians in the group got together one day and went up to Merrifield, Virginia and we recorded the music and the track. We arranged all the vocal parts with Joe’s help and put the thing together and took a cassette of that track back to the engagement that evening and played it for Frank – he was unaware of it. You all know Frankie Valli is just an extraordinary vocal singer – but he is also a quick study – he listened to the track and said “That’s not bad at all”.

Demetri asked Frankie “When we get off tonight will you get in the car with Lee, Gerry, Joe and myself at 12.00/12.30 in the morning and we will drive an hour and a half to go to the studio in Virginia and we would like you to sing the lead vocal on this otherwise it is worthless and he said ‘Sure why not I’ll do this’. I didn’t expect him to say this but he did. So at 2 a.m. we arrived at the studio in Maryfield which belonged to Teddy, a friend of mine”. Demetri added “We employed a trumpet player who came in at that hour of the morning, who did a session for $50 and I just recently found out that he is a professor at a music school in Winchester, Virginia, so we probably altered his career”! He continues.....“The point I really wanted to make aside from the fact that we enjoyed doing that session, was that Frankie was so nice, such a wonderful man, even though we performed together, he agreed at 2 a.m. in the morning to drive up to some unknown studio in the state of Virginia to do this recording and in 2 hours he had in my opinion, and those of you who have heard it, listen to his vocal, it speaks for itself, the notes he was hitting, I thought maybe he had eaten a box of bird seed before he done this because the notes he hit were just phenomenal.”

“Frankie had listened to the song en-route – he listened to this track in the car. We get in the studio – he gets into the studio – he is the only one now who has to perform to the backing track with our vocals – Frankie’s vocal is the only thing we need to do. By 4 a.m. he had put his vocal on this and my view is he had never heard this before but by 4 a.m. he - in my opinion - had sung superbly beyond my expectations”.

“Our biggest disappointment is that after it was done and Frank was excited about this – he called Bob Gaudio at 4 a.m. and woke him up and said ‘Listen to this’. So he holds the ‘phone up to the play back speakers in the studio and played the two and a half, three minutes of the song, and I do recall that, and Bob commented to Frankie that he liked it ‘Yes I think it could be a hit’! …....So Lee and I took the only master tape of that recording, we took it from the studio hoping to market it for selling and we went to Hollywood – we went to Motown ….... and we spoke with this wonderful lady, Suzanne De Passe, who I think has become President or is or was President …….this was over 40 years ago – and she said ‘We like that, we’d like to release it’. So we’re ecstatic! We leave the tape and go back to New York.“

Chapter 5 illustration

Joe Long who was able to ‘save’ the only copy of the recording of ‘I Wonder Why’

It has never seen the light of day since and only a salvaged copy from Joe Long's cassette archive has survived. Such was the reality of Motown. It was probably binned even though Motown did 'on the road' 'live recordings' throughout this period. It has however survived through the fan groups and with 2022 ‘sound engineering technology’ has been released in the Snapper Music as it’s first and best sounding ‘official release’. No credit goes to Motown.

So given this experience and the musical and vocal quality of the group at this time, a hit 45 was needed to create some belief within Motown that Valli and the group could succeed, but with so much still in the vaults today, it is impossible to assess the quality of the work or say if Motown’s ineptness was a result of the chaos within the label [post the demise of MoWest] or some other management issues involving Berry Gordy. All we have to go on are the subsequent tracks released on the ‘Inside You’ album (MW852) which was issued after the group had left the label in 1975 and the 2020 push by us in the Snapper Music research team to get all of the tapes retrieved from Iron Mountain, ‘digitized’ and sent to Bob Gaudio for evaluation). [None of the Research Team were supplied copies at that time.] After review with Frankie Valli, Bob Gaudio would however ,only give approval to 13 previously unreleased tracks found as complete mixed tracks for issue out a potential 30+ recovered. Paul Nixon ( an established Motown Music Collection Producer) recalled being told directly by Andy Skurrow , the then Mowtown archivist [in 2020] — one of the very few people, alongside Bob Gaudio, to have reviewed the salvaged Motown tapes — that - the remaining unreleased songs/tracks were [in his opinion] of the same quality as the tracks ‘approved’ by Bob Gaudio. No-one in Motown in the 1970s or since has paid much attention to the work put into Crewe-Gaudio’s search for a successful sound. But the Motown Unreleased Campaign by this Society continues to fight for release of the Master Session Tape contents which have all survived in the Iron Mountain storage as evidenced by paper records uncovered by the UK fan group.

Bob Gaudio was also trying again to get a hit sound with Valli in mid 1973 and produced the ballad 'The Scalawag Song' (aka 'Silver Fishes', 'And I Will Love You’) which was the planned title song for a Kirk Douglas film (it never made it on to the movie soundtrack). It was an August 1973 master mix and would appear on a Frankie Valli 45 in Dec 1973 on Motown 1279F along (once again) with 'Listen To Yesterday' [the female backed version]. One other session tape from May 1974 indicates Bob Gaudio attempted to generate something with 4 more songs (Tape 2678), 'Whatever You Want', 'Future Years' 'You Can't Hold On' and 'Getting Over You' but these would quickly be denoted as 'out of spec' [on Artists Cards] as the group's contract was running out. 'Whatever You Want' is the Jerry Butler classic penned by Crewe and Gaudio back in 1962 and the result is a beautiful harmony laced ballad with Beach Boys type harmonies again by Motown's high quality male background singers. Of these sessions the up-tempo 'You Can't Hold On', ‘Whatever You Want’ and the powerful ballad 'Future Years' eventually saw release is 2023, as part of a superb 22 track CD of ‘unreleased tracks in the Snapper Music Anthology Box Set.

Below is the Safety Copy Tape Bob Gaudio had put in his LA Storage – and all are ‘Alternate Mixes’

Chapter 5 illustration

With a strong instrumental and vocal line-up of ‘Four Seasons’ by the fall of 1974, [and with Motown agreement], Bob Crewe took the whole ensemble into the studios at Media Sound in NYC and completed sessions in November. He even persuaded Nick Massi to rejoin to help develop the vocal harmonies. Charles Calello returned as arranger and the scene was set for ‘success’....or so the group thought. For these sessions Crewe had several songs composed with 'Eleventh Hour' member Kenny Nolan who he had befriended earlier in the year.

Examination of the archives and releases of 1973 show how Crewe and Kenny Nolan were trying to achieve success for Valli solo and with the group. “Kenny Nolan was a Los Angeles falsetto type singer and song writer who was lead singer in the group called Eleventh Hour. The group was produced and managed by Bob Crewe and Kenny Nolan who was quoted to be a second Frankie Valli with reservations! “ recalls George Ingram.

The reality of these times is again best summed up by Rex Woodard who stated…...“Before the end of 1973, the Four Seasons finally played Las Vegas, three years later than once hoped. (A few years later, they became the third act to be invited to headline at the new International Hotel, following Presley and Sinatra). They also did several television spots for the first time in 10 years. Gaudio may have played due to the large audience. If the light lay at the end of the tunnel it shone too dimly for Callas. Callas enjoyed the Four Seasons but no longer believed there would be a “comeback”. He gracefully gave notice to begin preparations for a replacement. He had played a very key role in the band; past experience dictated that great care had to be taken in selecting his successor to avert another disaster. Demetri was slightly more pragmatic about the event saying....”I sensed my dismissal was nearing while performing with the Seasons. I was irresponsible....not a good team player.....and failed to thoroughly grasp the importance of the position that was afforded me by Bob and Frank. I chose to walk. It would be fair to say that I did not believe the Seasons would prevail as hit-makers. I was wrong; the Seasons continued to produce great recordings and to perform for decades.”

Joshua Baer recalls how Don ‘Cyclone’ Ciccone was recruited......”In 1973 Don Ciccone was a studio musician living in New York City. Because he was rarely home, he attached a recording device to his telephone. One night, in the course of playing back the day’s calls, Don came across the message that would turn him into a Four Season.

“The voice,” Don explains, “said, ‘Hello, this is Frankie Valli of The Four Seasons. We’d like you to get in touch with us as soon as you can’. I was stunned. I mean, the last time I’d even thought about The Four Seasons was when I was a freshman at Villanova. This friend of mine and I were supposed to do all the set designs for the big campus auditorium. As it turned out, The Four Seasons were the first show that came to town after we got the job. We put together some stupid thing, a painted backdrop of four trees going through the different seasons – very original, you know. But I got a free ticket to the show, and I went, and I thought they were really great. But I never dreamed I’d be playing with them someday”. Frankie Valli needed a band to tour with after the March [1973] debacle, so the two of them (Gaudio and Valli) had decided to collect four singing musicians who could back up Valli and faithfully reproduce old Four Seasons material. Half through instinct and half through intention, they hired four excellent musicians who were, as it turned out, not unlike themselves when they started out in The Four Lovers.”

Rex Woodard recalls.....”Ciccone’s credentials were impressive. Born 28 February 1946 Ciccone enjoyed the national spotlight in the mid ‘60s as lead singer, lead guitarist and composer for the Critters. A ‘draft notice’ cut short this moment in the limelight. He returned from the army, cut a solo album for Buddah (never released) and commenced a successful career recording commercials and doing session work. Valli had no way of knowing so, but Ciccone had been a Four Seasons fan ever since catching them in concert in 1965. The audition was waived; Ciccone joined effective 1 January 1974. The group opened 1974 on 15 January when asked to play at the inauguration of New Jersey’s Governor. Ciccone didn’t feel familiar enough with the material to perform but Callas agreed to return for the event.

Crewe and Kenny Nolan had penned a delightful number entitled “Hickory” which seemed earmarked for platinum. Recent developments dictated Motown would contribute minimum promotion, but Crewe felt “Hickory” would sell itself if the Seasons covered it. Crewe commemorated the “Hickory/Charisma” recording sessions by reuniting the original team that placed the Seasons in the number one position before the Beatles arrived. Calello, a member of the Four Seasons briefly in 1958 and again in 1965, and who did all those fabulous arrangements on Vee Jay and Philips, returned. (Calello had temporarily left his religious group for the occasion) So did Nick Massi, the original bassist between 1960 and 1965. Valli sang lead, with background vocals provided by Massi, Crewe (also pounding on a tambourine), Gaudio, Long and no telling who else.[actually Shapiro and Polci] The song turned out very nicely. Valli’s falsettos were sharp and Massi’s bass notes (particularly on “Charisma”) touched many a nostalgic old fan. [the extended version recovered on the 2008 Motown Anthology best illustrated this comment..ed]

The tracks 'Hickory' and 'Charisma' were deemed strong enough for single release from these Nov/Dec 1973 sessions and appeared on Motown 1288 in February 1974.

“Hickory” received respectable airplay in several markets, and pierced the top Billboard Hot 100 [at 94] and in most national surveys. It got no promotion, as feared. Still, it seemed a step in the right direction. Crewe asked Motown to release “My Eyes Adored You” also a Crewe/Nolan composition, as a follow-up. Motown refused. It was the final straw. It was time to move on.” As Rex Woodard concludes...” Crewe and Gaudio cut eight solo Valli sides before the end of the year, including “My Eyes Adored You”. Crewe recalls that Motown not only did not like their songs but was “downright puzzled” as to what compelled them to think anyone else would.”

Chapter 5 illustration

But by the June residency at Bachelors III in Fort Lauderdale Frankie had made another crucial recruitment decision as Rex tells us….”To strengthen the stage act which continued to tour very successfully, the group added a guitarist to the back-up band, John Paiva. He could be spotted back in the shadows beginning 6 May 1974.” By then the group were in conflict with Motown and threatening to not renew their 3 year contract. Strangely before their departure and perhaps as an attempt to persuade them to stay at the label Motown proposed a new album release from their recent sessions…..too little too late and their departure was inevitable.

John Paiva was however happy after years as a ‘troubadour’ playing with many groups since the mid sixties. He was a superbly talented guitarist. He recalls how he was recruited as a LIVE band member in his biography........“After one particular show, we (The Happenings) finished our last song and as we were taking our final bows to an uninterested audience a tall smiling football player type came gangling up the isle with his hand out wishing me well and loading me up with compliments. Gerry Polci was his name. He told me that he was a member of “The Four Seasons” and that they were playing at the Melody Tent nearby. Again he said how much he enjoyed my playing. .... Fine and good night. Gerry did give me his phone num- ber and soon I found myself contacting him. That’s when I became impressed. He was forever returning from or off to some neat place I had never seen. This all sounded grand. No promises were ever made but one day I did get called. Would I be interested in a possible gig with the group as second guitarist. Swell with me, so I took a cut in pay and joined up.

The call for the Seasons gig was unusual. My first notice that there might be something possible, came from Gerry, saying someone would contact me soon. Joe Labracio [Long] who was then the bassist and bass singer called. We met at his apartment in New Jersey not far from my place in North Plainfield. During the meeting I began to get the feeling that the opening was more for a roadie than a second guitarist. I was adamant that I had no interest in setting up equipment. Joe claimed that although I would be traveling with Duke [Natoli] in the van rather than flying, I would not be expected to handle equipment. That turned out to be bullshit. After traveling with and becoming good friends with Duke, it became uncomfortable to just sit there. I felt obligated to pitch in and soon found myself jerking gear around the country as a glorified roadie. This was not to my taste!” Nor did it help a bad back! “

Rex also noted that....”Valli’s temperament improved too no end when wedding bells chimed for him and Mary Ann Hannagan on 29 June 1974. Mary Ann, a 25 year old model, befriended Valli earlier at a time when the world seemed to be crashing in on his head. They held a brief ceremony in Las Vegas with Gaudio standing as best man.“

Mid 1974 was to also to become the 'NEW' Four Seasons early peak. With Joe, Lee, Don and Gerry, and John Paiva in the backing band, Frankie Valli had the best ever set of musician’s that had ever worked LIVE with him. Fans recall this as the best sounding ‘line-up’.

Chapter 5 illustration

This is best exemplified in the concerts at Bachelor’s 3 – Fort Lauderdale in June 1974. For years the shows had contained a masterful mixture of the oldies hits plus contemporary songs done in innovative arrangements which maintained the groups connection with the newer fans and emerging audiences whilst still being true to the ‘roots’ music created by the ‘original’ Four Seasons back in the 60s. Many of these contemporary songs had been around since the early 70s like, ‘I Got Love’ , from the musical 'Purlie', which Charles Calello had arranged for them......and their awesome medley of ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water/ Long and Winding Road/McArthur Park’. But with Lee Shapiro’s developing skills other new material was added. ‘You Are The Sunshine Of My Life’, the Stevie Wonder classic was given a harmony style and Frankie’s voice was allowed to soar on Paul McCartney’s ‘My Love’ and the contemporary classics, ‘Memories/All In Love Is Fair’ and David Gates ‘If’, also showed Lee’s superb arranging talents. The group also flexed their musical talents and as well as a fast paced version of ‘If I Were A Carpenter’ and they also did an instrumental spot featuring Barry White’s ‘Love Theme'. At no other stage in the history of the Four Seasons did the group perform a show with so many unrecorded tracks nor deliver such a versatile and diverse show. None of these songs were ever recorded in the studio. The sound was clearly improved with John Paiva as part of the backing band and his guitar 'fills' were a feature of their sound with him being introduced by Frankie Valli as ...”My Main Man! John Paiva”. The backing of The Memphis Horns also showed what a full Four Seasons Orchestra could achieve.

Rex Woodard again takes up the story in mid 1974....“The group decided to leave Motown. Berry Gordy’s intentions were honourable when he signed the boys but shortly thereafter he discovered movie making and apparently lost interest in making records. Motown never paid royalties to the group. It found promotion difficult since the whole company structure was centred on black enterprise and thus unequipped for dealing with the white market. Vee Jay had been the same but the industry had been different in those days. Valli tried to buy from Motown the unreleased album tracks but their price was too high. He ended up taking just the master of “My Eyes Adored You” for $4,600.” (according to sources close to Bob Crewe). An 'alternate vocal' [New Mix] remained in the Partnership LA Storage and was found for release in 2023. The amazing discovery from an investigation of the Partnership vaults in 2020 was that Motown proposed an album and single release to persuade the group to stay.[Tapes P5084/5] A full album was prepared with many of the tracks from these final sessions with Bob Crewe and Bob Gaudio. 'The Night b/w You Can't Hold On’ was prepared as a 45 release but by no-one in the Four Seasons Partnership, the group or in Bob Crewe believed in Motown after 4 years of under promotion or release of such ‘unheard’ till 2023 quality material.

They knew they could get better deals and both Crewe and Gaudio were testing the market. Attempts to take other songs with them failed as the cost of session recordings was at the time ‘charged to the group’s contract account’. Whilst Frankie Valli left the label, Crewe, Gaudio and Nolan were still contracted to Jobete (Motown’s music publishing company) and several subsequent recordings would show these publishing credentials although it is apparent that none of them were recorded whilst at Motown. However the master of ‘My Eyes Adored You’ was. “Crewe and Valli hustled “Eyes” to Capital, Atlantic, Tom Cat and other labels but no one bit.” As Charles Calello recalls, “The Seasons had a bad run at Motown and not a label in the states was interested in them. 32 labels passed on "My Eye's Adored You" when Bob Gaudio, Frankie Valli and Bob Crewe tried to sell it.”. Rex Woodard again recalls..“They finally found a taker in Larry Uttal, former president of Bell Records. Uttal almost signed the original Four Seasons back in 1960 and regretted his lack of foresight later. Uttal had just formed a new independent label, Private Stock, and needed artists. He could hear potential in “My Eyes Adored You” and really believed he could break it big. Unfortunately, his belief extended only to that particular record. He did not want to place the Four Seasons [new line-up]under contract, only Valli individually. This was still a workable arrangement, at least the song would get released, and the group’s value could later rise in proportion to Valli’s own fortunes.” Charles Calello recalls...”Bob Crewe’s engineer Roy Cicalla remixed the track at the Sound Studio in LA “. Valli signed to Private Stock in October 1974 and the song was the labels first release.

“My Eyes Adored You” when also released in the UK made good steady progress prompting a 'promo' visit by Valli. Released in October 74 it peaked reaching #5 by February 1975.(Valli’s first UK chart entry since 1971 with ‘The Proud One’ at #48). In the USA the song had entered the Billboard ‘Bubbling Under’ chart on 16 November 1974 at No 103. “ ........ And began slowly climbing the charts.

“Valli continued to perform the track in concert throughout the latter half of 1974,” according to Rex Woodard. Finally, on 22 March 1975 Billboard pro- claimed “My Eyes Adored You” – Private Stock 4503 (b/w ‘Watch Were You Walk’) as the nation’s number one record after almost six months since its release! One of the longest running releases to climb eventually to #1, proving finally that Motown had got it wrong.

Chapter 5 illustration

But over in the UK something else from the past was emerging to ensure the resurgence of the group was assured...... as documented in a Four Seasons UK Appreciation Society Newsletter by Ken Charmer:-

“Back in the UK the Northern Soul scene was to become a phenomena that was irresistible and with it the NEW Four Seasons resurgence began. In a small town in Lancashire at 2.00 am on 23 September 1973 Wigan Casino [a dancehall and NOT a 'casino'] opened its doors to 1,500 underground music fanatics. The DJ’s, staff and enthusiasts would create a monster which grew and grew and became an institution for thousands of youngsters. The Casino legend not only influenced the national pop charts but spawned its own record label and magazine. By 1977 it would be voted by Billboard the worlds best disco, beating, amongst others, the then trendy Studio 54 in New York. Kev Roberts, one of the clubs early DJ’s, held the Seasons in high esteem!!! He recalls….“The Seasons had become popular at the ‘Twisted Wheel’, Manchester in 1969. I’ll always remember starting my first ever session at Wigan Casino on 30 September 1973 with ‘I’m Gonna Change’. Everybody loved this track and it was regularly featured but this popularity was to grow in the years that followed culminating in their most famous[at the time] Northern Soul track”.

In England Northern Soul became the dominant club sound. In Wigan’s Casino the reputations of the DJ’s, in particular Russ Winstanley and Richard Searling, were escalating and the all-nighters were playing, for many people’s money the rarest and best-quality Northern Soul sounds anywhere in the UK. The Northern scene record hunters were turning up totally obscure American singles, little known B-sides, unknown British releases and stunning album tracks with great regularity. Russ comments on how he ‘broke’ the Seasons on the Northern Soul scene. 'Another Casino related ‘hit’ was by an already established artist Frankie Valli. Together with the Four Seasons he cut ‘The Night’ with the Motown linked label MoWest.”' I picked up on the recording and it went down a storm at the Casino. From the opening bass guitar to its storming conclusion, it was hugely popular.”

Chapter 5 illustration

Wigan Casino was voted the ‘Best Disco In The World’ in 1978. Click the image to see the fan inspired version

As a result of the Northern Soul interest, Motown/MoWest re-issued ‘The Night’ and it actually 'stormed' up the UK charts in Spring 1975 [as Frankie Valli also rode the charts with 'My Eyes Adored You']. Demand had built up throughout 1974 from the club scene and The Four Seasons became a dance floor favourite, confirming their cult following and the respect Northern Soul fans had for the group. Reissued on MoWest 3024 during Feb1975, sales were sufficient to see ’The Night’ enter the UK Pop charts on 19 April where it would stay for 9 weeks and peak at #7 on 16th May 1975. Success at last from the ‘Chameleon’ album after 3 years!

All this activity in the US and UK charts caused a reaction.......back in the USA.......as Charles Calello comments:-

“The big name rock chroniclers awoke from their slumber about this time and began taking notice of this simple ditty by the “former lead singer” of the famous Four Seasons. Uttal can be credited with one of the best, most persistent promotion efforts of all time. “My Eyes...” only jumped three or four notches a week, but Uttal kept plugging away. “

Chapter 5 illustration

Bob Crewe was riding a wave of success as 1974 rolled into 1975 with the Disco Age and the rise of the NYC gay club scene. He found chart topping success (#1 March 23rd 1975) with ‘Lady Marmalade’ (Epic 50048) by Labelle (knocking ‘My Eyes..’ off the #1 spot) and chart action with Disco-Tex and The Sex-O-Lettes But Crewe had also shown his innate hit making ability and provided the hit follow on Valli needed with “Swearin’ To God” a Bob Crewe/Denny Randell song. It was on Private Stock 45012 (b/w ‘Why’), and released and debuted in May 75. It sold 317,625 copies in its first 10 days on the street hitting #6. In the UK it was released the same month making #31 in June. [It was also released in it’s full length Club Mix on a 12 inch release PVT-21 DJ and the only surviving Master of that version is here on my You Tube Page]

In early 1975 Bob Crewe was still in his long struggle with alcoholism and whilst on the way to an AA meeting there was a ‘hit and run’ road accident that left him hospitalised and close to death with over 20 fractures which would end any chances of him working any magic with Valli for some time and he faced a long fight back to health. So it meant Bob Gaudio had to finish the 'Closeup' album at Private Stock for Valli after having split the track production …...but he finished the album with the help of Kenny Nolan and arranger Charles Calello. Crewe survived the accident and after months in a body cast and would return with his own “Motivation’ solo album and establish himself again as a recovering addict to collaborate as a co-producer and writer for the ‘Heaven Above Me’ album by 1979 with Bob Gaudio and Frankie Valli.

He had salvaged Valli's career from the dire days of Motown's mis-management and too this day we can see and hear the hard work Crewe/Gaudio and Valli in particular put in on those session tapes with some 20+ tracks from the Motown contract days [according to records] still in the vaults at Universal Motown. The 13 tracks which have surfaced in 2023 show the stunning quality we first realised on the ‘Inside You’ album of mainly unreleased songs in 1976. And we also have the ‘Alternate Mixes’ which make up the rest of the 22 track ‘Unreleased Motown CD in the Snapper Music Box Set.

But there was a change coming. Frankie Valli in a UK interview in early 1975 knew there was better to come when asked about the Group he said “I have a monster that I am holding back until the summer, its going to be a number 1"

Word circulated fast that the Four Seasons were unsigned and available in late 1974. Mike Curb was a good friend of Bob Gaudio at the time and Bob knew he had something special in terms of a new song for the NEW Four Seasons. To whet his appetite, Gaudio would let them hear a song written while at Motown [and he was still a contracted writer at the label at the end of 1974 so it was under their ownership on Jobete Publishing] The song was “Who Loves You”. Gaudio and Valli paid for the session. But not with Valli singing it. The demo recorded by Gaudio featured Don Ciccone on lead vocal. “with the patented Seasons harmony soaring in the background. The song had disco appeal but made the best disco music in the land seem wimpy in comparison.” says Rex Woodard. Gaudio maintains however that he never wrote it as a disco song.

After the success of 'The Night' for the group and Frankie's resurgence in 1975 [at Warner-Curb and Private Stock respectively] The ‘Chameleon’ album was also re-issued in the UK [Mowest MWS 7006] in June 1975. Bob Fisher the UK Press Officer at Motown UK persuaded the label to issue 'Life And Breath' b/w 'Thank You' [Mowest M3034] from the Motown assembled ‘cash-in’ album ‘Inside You’ in June 1976 and it achieved #52 in the UK single charts. He thought it was a natural follow-on to 'My Eyes Adored You'. The 'B' side even found a place with Northern Soul fans. Too many tracks remain unreleased however given the 50 + years since recording. This still represents a huge gap in the musical history of the group and doesn’t do justice to Valli and the group members who appeared in what fans recall as great ‘live’ performances during this time.

The beginning of 1975 should have been a settled and steady time for the group. But even when musically they were at their best, internal pressures [frictions between Joe Long and Lee Shapiro] and external influences came into play. Of course, such internal pressures had dogged them through the 1970s and have affected every major pop group in the past 50 years: consider the Beatles, the Rolling Stones and the Who, just for starters. "I think it's outside influences that are always circling a group," Gaudio says of these times .When the decision was made by Frankie and Bob that Joe Long should be ‘retired’ from the group in 1975 there were a number of reasons quoted in interviews and anecdotal information. One was that he was having problems hitting bass notes due to his early 60s hand injury. Another was that he wanted to be made a partner with Bob and Frankie. And a third was that he was dropped because a younger image was required.....this it has been suggested was due to Mary Anne’s influence. However if that was the case Bob Gaudio as well as Frankie must have gone along with the idea. Maybe Frankie supports this reason in a 2010 interview when he says..."We've all been influenced by people we've been with. And that's unfortunate, sometimes." Frankie Valli told David Gritten Telegraph in March 2008. In examining these reasons, the first has been discounted by John Paiva who would have noticed if Joe had any trouble hitting notes and the second by Joe himself in interview with Stuart Miller. The friction between Joe and Lee however had been happening since Demetri Callas was still with the group and after Don and John joined the line-up was having an impact on performances. But the ambitions of the younger members also made Bob and Frankie take notice.

Whatever the reason it was one not welcomed by the fans. Many deserted the US fan club and the group lost a large chunk of audience connection and personality on stage from which they would never recover. One UK fan Malcolm Grace captured what Joe was all about .... “Without doubt my favourite Season is Joe Long. I have often thought I would like to tell him so and that after all these years, how a small event explains why......... “The first time I saw the Seasons was at the Hammersmith Odeon in 1971. I took a friend of a girl I was trying to take out. After the show Tina suggested going round to the Stage Door and trying to get Frankie's autograph. There were about 30 of us. We got a resounding "Get Lost" by the staff and most left. There were about 6 of us when Bob Grimm came through and told us there was a reception on the front upstairs foyer. "Go On Up." Yeah Right! Anyway we did and huddled around the top of the staircase. It was Joe who saw us first and he beckoned us over but we all froze. Then he walked over and said "Come on in as My Guests" and asked a waitress to give us some drinks and food. He noticed that Tina and I had programmes and asked if we wanted them signed and did so and then went over to Frankie and Bob and got them to sign too. As I was only 18 I didn't know what to say apart from Thanks!”

John Paiva in his biography gives his take on the situation of Joes’ retirement and his move to the front from the backing band.... “Frank and Bob Gaudio lived on the west coast. I figured that I would have the next few weeks off as it would surely take that long to get the material together and as Don was the guitarist, I would not be needed. A couple of days after they left I got a call from Lee saying that I should join the group in Los Angeles to help on the 'Who Loves You' album. “You’re needed to help with the gear.” I was on salary so off I flew. “Bring along your guitar will you!?” “Why?” “Don wants to use it in the studio.” Don was my friend by then so if he would like to borrow my guitar, sure, why not? I was met at LAX by Lee who left me at the hotel, as there was a meeting that afternoon between Bob Gaudio and the guys........... without Joe. That appeared curious. Lee suggested that Joe and I could hang together and DO LUNCH!! People in LA don’t eat lunch, they DO LUNCH!! So, Joe and I did some lunch and had a pleasant afternoon. Things could have been worse. The group was picking up the tab and I loved California. Later when the guys returned, I was invited to Lee’s room to talk with him as well as Don and Gerry. They laid the 'bomb' on me. Joe was being let go and I would play guitar and sing on the album as well as perhaps act as the out of season guy until they found a suitable replacement. It didn’t cross my mind that I was being considered for the chair.

Joe had been bassist and bass singer for over 15 years and was with the group almost from its infancy. He seemed an indispensable and important member. Frankie and Joe 'kibitzed' through every show with many 'off 'color gay jokes. That was the way for some in those days. He was certainly entertaining and had a warm relationship with the fans. Just the same, Joe was getting the ax. The reasoning as explained to me, was that Joe had fallen behind in the times. Slap bass and newer grooves were popular and Joe was in a time warp, it was maintained. I hadn’t noticed. He played the show fine........but he did give Lee[who is Jewish] a hard time with some abuse. This was something Lee and Joe 'set to rights' with no hard feelings prior to Joe's passing in 2021.

But decision time was here and it was up to me to join and I said 'yes'. I was told I would get studio pay. That sounded very interesting. We could sure use the extra bread at home. One of the reasons for Joe perhaps falling behind was his left hand. As a young guy starting out he had a sideline repairing sewing machines. In an accident his left hand got seriously damaged and screwed up his playing. He is right handed, but went on to overcome this problem by learning to play left handed, which was a big challenge. Thereby his left hand was used to attack the strings while his right was free to play the fretboard. Changing around must not have been an easy thing to do, but he did it!

Okay, so be it. I was glad to get the offer. Naturally I figured Joe would get some big bread upon leaving and wouldn’t be hurting.. He certainly had earned his share. I assume he did get something if only as a reward for having been so long with the organization.”, But whatever the rumours perhaps the 'coming together' of the story is within the interview Joe gave to former UK fan club President Stuart Miller re his feelings on the ‘retirement’ saying.....” After Bob (Gaudio) left in 1971 we went through a whole series of replacement guys. The further we got into that area, the less connection there was with these guys and the old group, and I told you before I respected what the group had done. The new guys like Lee Shapiro, I’m not sure how old he was when “Sherry” came out, you know.! Their whole 'musical idea' was very different from mine. At the same time Gaudio, and this was from my perspective, this was how I looked at it, he had visions of separating the group. Sending the 4 Seasons out as a group and sending Frankie out as an act on his own, splitting them, which he actually did do. ….... Meantime, and word came back to me through the back up musicians, certain guys on the band were saying “Joe Long is like a dinosaur and he’s holding us back and we’ll never be able to make it on our own with Joe. We need a fresher, younger thinking guy”. And I think Bobby began to agree with them, you know. Now this is my perspective. So we talked about it. I was beginning to feel a lot of negativity and a lot of pressure back from the other guys anyway by this time. They weren’t that happy that I was around. Plus I represented, again in my mind, a throwback to the old guys so ”get rid of the last vestige of the old regime and now we got our own little kingdom out here, you know?” And so Bob decided that maybe it was better if I wasn’t there. That was my idea of what happened ......... I never asked to be a partner. I did ask at times for a little better cut of the pie but I think that’s normal. You get a job, you think you’re doing a good job. When I first came into the band I was hired as Nicky’s replacement. Within a year I was Mc’ing the band, I was conducting the musicians whenever we used an augmented orchestra. I was going out doing promotions. I was actually doing more than what Nicky had been doing.” And when asked if he was disappointed with the way it was handled? He said...” Oh absolutely, absolutely. I felt that my loyalty meant nothing. That the 11 or 12 years that I spent with them meant nothing because I was very easily dispensed with in favour of three other guys who had no loyalty. I hope I’m not sounding vicious on this Stuart but I was disappointed. I don’t think I would have stayed much longer with the band anyway because I didn’t like the direction the band was taking but the way it was handled I thought was just not proper.”

But he adds...”They treated me OK. I was earning money from them for a year afterwards, pretty good money as a matter of fact. It was a separation. They treated me well throughout the whole thing. It must have been tough on them. Really tough. Frankie wasn’t even in the country when it happened. Frankie went over to England. [promoting 'My Eyes Adored You'] I sometimes wonder whether he wanted to be as far away as possible from the whole thing. It must have been a very, very tough thing for them to have to do. I’m not angry for what they did. I’m angry for the way they did it. “ Joe left the group September1975. Joe left shortly after Valli and the Seasons co-hosted the Mike Douglas TV show for the full week of September 1, 1975. Lee Shapiro's arranging and conducting skill were clearly a major asset whilst Joe's skills were in 'M'cing'. But Joe had no justification for his ‘abusive behaviour’ directed at Lee Shapiro. As a result there is one thing that stands out in retrospect re this sad decision and that is that, at no time did anyone consider how the fans might react.....or how much they genuinely loved Joe Long. But there was perhaps no alternative. Rex Woodard recalls...”The news of Long’s intended departure later caused shock waves in the Four Seasons Fan Club; two officers resigned, citing Long’s loss as the rationale. Down deep, many feared that the new album would be inferior and damage the group’s heritage. Guitarist John Paiva was promoted up to Seasondom to take Long’s spot. Paiva, born 25 January 1943, previously belonged to The Happenings, the Time Machine, Cal Ray and the Classaires, and the back-up band for the Platters. His elevation required Don Ciccone to make the difficult transition from lead guitar to bass guitar.”

Chapter 5 illustration

Joe’s final recording with the group was ‘Who Loves You’ on a backing track prepared without Frankie who was in England. With Warner-Curb clamouring for the track, Don Ciccone filled in on lead....but Mike Curb wanted Frankie’s vocal on it as soon as he got back.

Don commented on how ‘Who Loves You’ came to be..... in an article in Goldmine...“Well let’s start off with the fact that Frankie Valli had a lull in his hit-making career of about seven years, like when he was with Motown. When the membership was finalized consisting of Joe Long, Lee Shapiro, Gerry Polci and myself, Bob Gaudio came out to hear us and felt for the first time since he’d left the group that it was worth signing to a production deal. He then looked for a record deal with the signed group. That was flattering to all of us. We wound up recording “Who Loves You” toward the very end of the year (1974). We rehearsed it for a few days and then went into the studio to put down the basic tracks. Frankie was not present for any of those sessions. We finished the recording December 30th and Bob said, “What are you guys gonna do to- morrow?” We said we all wanted to go back and be with our families for New Year’s Eve. This was like three o’clock in the morning and we still didn’t have a lead vocal, so he asked if one of us would stay and put down a lead vocal. Everyone kinda looked at each other but I jumped at the chance. I really wanted to be home with my wife and daughter but I felt it was a good career move. So the next day I went in and learned the song, wrote out a lyric sheet and did about five takes on it. This was just supposed to be a reference lead for Frankie to be able to learn the tune. So I did it to where I thought it was just enough, not a great performance, and weeks went by [ Frankie had a tendency to procrastinate a lot ] before Frankie went into the studio to learn the tune. Meanwhile, Mike Curb – we’d signed with Warner/Curb Records – kept calling, asking when he was gonna get to hear this tune. So Gaudio finally said, “The heck with it, Frankie, I’m playing it for him with Don’s lead vocal.” Well, Warner Brothers loved the song so much they wanted to put it out with my reference lead on it. When Frankie heard that, that spurred him to go in and change the vocal and insist that his vocal be the one used. I thought that was the right thing to do – it was Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons – and I wasn’t looking for an ego trip. I was already on one just being in the Four Seasons. Not that I would’ve turned down being a lead vocalist. So that was put out and became a monster record “ That rare demo version with Don's vocal got its first commercial release in 2023 in the Snapper Box Set.

In the UK with ‘Swearin’ To God’ having hit #31 in the June, Motown continued to attempt to cash in on the success of ‘The Night’ with the release in the same month of ‘Touch The Rainchild/Poor Fool ‘(Mowest 3028), both from the previously unsuccessful 'Chameleon' album, and the album itself was also re-released. Motown 'owned the recordings at the label’ and wanted to cash in......all a bit late in the day.

“‘Who Loves You’ was released in the UK on 12th September 1975 and in that week it had been Noel Edmonds Breakfast Show record of the week on BBC Radio 1, He played it every day and when he got to the middle he promo’d it and started it again and more than once playing the "disco" side. He described it as a totally new sound. It was a sensation”...recalls Malcolm Grace. It reached #6 being on the chart for 9 weeks through September and October. In America it faired even better and peaked at #3 and remained on the charts for 12 weeks.

Whilst escape from Motown to find success shows things can happen ‘twice’ as they had left Vee-Jay in 1963 to find success at Philips.......and in the same way Motown cashed in as had Vee-Jay by releasing their catalogue tracks too after their departure from the label, so history was in a way repeating itself now in 1975.

The issue of the ‘Inside You’ LP in April 1976 would finally [well for 47 years] close the Motown Story.

Whatever the rest of the world thought of the Four Seasons and Frankie Valli at Mowest and Motown the UK fans now really took them and this period to their hearts in retrospect buying all of these un-promoted previous releases. Motown trawled their tapes and constructed this album with mostly unreleased tracks from 1972 and 1973 sessions with a variety of producers. The resulting album cemented US and UK fans belief that this virtually 'lost' period at Motown was in fact a 'golden' age most fans of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons recordings had simply missed and it was all down to Motown's mismanagement. The UK release of Inside You [MoWest MWS 7007] on April 30th, 1976 is the ‘definitive version’ of this album, containing twelve tracks rather than the meagre nine of its American equivalent. The disc gives artist credit to just Valli although six songs (including ‘Hickory’, ‘Charisma’ and ’Walk On Don't Look Back’) are really Four Seasons’ recordings. According to reports in 1975, Bob Gaudio 'cringed' when he learned of the release since he had had no role in the final mixing or selections [viz...’With My Eyes Wide Open’]. Still, the record stands as Valli’s last predominantly falsetto collection ever while at the label [until 2023 with a release of 13 unheard tracks and 8 'alternate' versions from the twenty-nine+ session multi-track tapes they left behind when they left the label.] At long last these events confirms Bob Gaudio’s comment in 1972 to be correct., “If you go on making ‘good product’, it will eventually ‘come good’”

Chapter 5 illustration

The NEW Four Seasons as labelled by Warner-Curb

Chapter 5 illustration

As I have sought to portray this is an amazing success story as a result of the combination of circumstances that enabled Frankie Valli and Bob Gaudio to reshape their careers out of the ‘dust and turmoil’ of the Motown years with Bob Crewe clearly saving Frankie Valli’s ‘solo’ career. But was it really as Rex Woodard maintains, 'A Lesson In Survival' ….......”a case of persistence, belief and an ability to survive”.....combined with the recruitment of some of the best vocal and musically skilled people in the business, at their right age......two incredible songs and the influence and lyric writing skills of a woman who would add the final piece to Bob Gaudio’s ‘lyric’ plan for a NEW Four Seasons.......Judy Parker. Or, was it ‘luck ‘and of course one other vital thing related to all of these....timing!, It was probably a combination of all these reasons. But as I have described to recover from a the setbacks of Motown, their failure, and near total collapse as a group and come back stronger, renewed, and more popular than before is their amazing achievement. The rise was unstoppable and driven by the best of the lot still to come. Who would have believed the group would explode so brilliantly in just 18 months....with the studio booked in November 1975 as they delivered the album everyone was waiting for. 'Who Loves You'.

Chapter References/Credits

References: Goldmine Article – The Four Seasons - A Lesson in Survival by Rex Woodard 1981: Article From A Warner Bros Circular November 1984 by Joshua Baer Titled “4 Seasons To Consider” ; “Out Of Season” by John Paiva (unpublished biography): Don Ciccone in Interview: Four Seasons UK Appreciation Society Newsletters: Interview with Joe Long by Stuart Miller; Special thanks to : Charles Calello: Frank Rovello: Ken Charmer: George Ingram: Lynn Boleyn: Ray Nichol: Malcolm Grace : Paul Nixon: Keith Hughes; Ken Charmer